Immersion Corporation of San Jose, CA holds 142 US patents, nearly all of which are related to haptic human-computer interfaces. From a conference call for Immersion shareholders: The case involved Immersion's allegation that Sony Computer Entertainment America, Inc. (SCEA) and Sony Computer Entertainment, Inc. (SCEI, the Japanese parent of SCEA) infringed 16 claims in two of our patents, U.S. Patent Number 6,275,213 and 6,424,333, relating to vibro-tactile technologies. The case was filed on February 11, 2002 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. The case has been pending before United States District Judge Claudia Wilken. It is worth noting that Microsoft was also named in this case on claims that the Xbox also infringed; they settled out of court. Here's 6,275,213. It's interesting to note that this isn't even their patent, originally. It was assigned to a company named Virtual Technologies, out of Palo Alto. Tactile feedback man-machine interface device Abstract: A man-machine interface which provides tactile feedback to various sensing body parts is disclosed. The device employs one or more vibrotactile units, where each unit comprises a mass and a mass-moving actuator. As the mass is accelerated by the mass-moving actuator, the entire vibrotactile unit vibrates. Thus, the vibrotactile unit transmits a vibratory stimulus to the sensing body part to which it is affixed. The vibrotactile unit may be used in conjunction with a spatial placement sensing device which measures the spatial placement of a measured body part. A computing device uses the spatial placement of the measured body part to determine the desired vibratory stimulus to be provided by the vibrotactile unit. In this manner, the computing device may control the level of vibratory feedback perceived by the corresponding sensing body part in response to the motion of the measured body part. The sensing body part and the measured body part may be separate or the same body part. U.S. Patent 6,424,333 is a continuation application of prior U.S. application Ser. No. 09/561,782, filed on May 1, 2000 now U.S. Pat. No. 6,275,213, in the name of Marc Tremblay, et al., which is a continuation of prior U.S. patent application Ser. No. 09/066,608, filed on Apr. 24, 1998 now U.S. Pat. No. 6,088,017, which is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 08/565,102, filed Nov. 30, 1995, abandoned; and all of which are incorporated herein by reference. From a law.com article in September 2004, here's a description of the alleged infringement: He said the PlayStation technology in dispute "is a very small subset of vibrations" that occur in a joystick during a small number of events per game. For example, he said, in "A Bug's Life," the ant in the game must jump first on an acorn, which then turns into a mushroom. Powers said the vibration in question occurs only when the ant jumps on the mushroom several times. From the same article, this quote was also amusing: "It takes a special breed of person to enjoy watching great patent lawyers try a case, and generally that breed of person is ill," said Harold McElhinny, a patent litigation partner at Morrison & Foerster. "The dramatic skills for openings and cross-examinations don't appear quite as often in patent cases where the subject matter is colorless. "I have to pay money to have my family come and watch me try a patent case," McElhinny joked. Here's a complete list of Immersion's patents: PAT. NO. Title 1 6,866,643 Determination of finger position 2 6,864,877 Directional tactile feedback for haptic feedback interface devices 3 6,859,819 Force feedback enabled over a computer network 4 6,850,222 Passive force feedback for computer interface devices 5 6,833,846 Control methods for the reduction of limit cycle oscillations for haptic devices with displacement quantization 6 6,822,635 Haptic interface for laptop computers and other portable devices 7 6,817,973 Apparatus for controlling force for manipulation of medical instruments 8 6,816,148 Enhanced cursor control using interface devices 9 6,801,008 Force feedback system and actuator power management 10 6,781,569 Hand controller 11 6,762,745 Actuator control providing linear and continuous force output 12 6,750,877 Controlling haptic feedback for enhancing navigation in a graphical environment 13 6,717,573 Low-cost haptic mouse implementations 14 6,715,045 Host cache for haptic feedback effects 15 6,707,443 Haptic trackball device 16 6,705,871 Method and apparatus for providing an interface mechanism for a computer simulation 17 6,704,683 Direct velocity estimation for encoders using nonlinear period measurement 18 6,704,002 Position sensing methods for interface devices 19 6,704,001 Force feedback device including actuator with moving magnet 20 6,703,550 Sound data output and manipulation using haptic feedback 21 6,697,748 Digitizing system and rotary table for determining 3-D geometry of an object 22 6,697,086 Designing force sensations for force feedback computer applications 23 6,697,048 Computer interface apparatus including linkage having flex 24 6,697,044 Haptic feedback device with button forces 25 6,697,043 Haptic interface device and actuator assembly providing linear haptic sensations 26 6,693,626 Haptic feedback using a keyboard device 27 6,693,622 Vibrotactile haptic feedback devices 28 6,686,911 Control knob with control modes and force feedback 29 6,686,901 Enhancing inertial tactile feedback in computer interface devices having increased mass 30 6,683,437 Current controlled motor amplifier system 31 6,680,729 Increasing force transmissibility for tactile feedback interface devices 32 6,661,403 Method and apparatus for streaming force values to a force feedback device 33 6,654,000 Physically realistic computer simulation of medical procedures 34 6,639,581 Flexure mechanism for interface device 35 6,636,197 Haptic feedback effects for control, knobs and other interface devices 36 6,636,161 Isometric haptic feedback interface 37 6,580,417 Tactile feedback device providing tactile sensations from host commands 38 6,564,168 High-resolution optical encoder with phased-array photodetectors 39 6,563,487 Haptic feedback for directional control pads 40 6,486,872 Method and apparatus for providing passive fluid force feedback 41 6,470,302 Interface device and method for interfacing instruments to vascular access simulation systems 42 6,469,692 Interface device with tactile feedback button 43 6,448,977 Textures and other spatial sensations for a relative haptic interface device 44 6,437,771 Force feedback device including flexure member between actuator and user object 45 6,429,846 Haptic feedback for touchpads and other touch controls 46 6,424,356 Command of force sensations in a forceback system using force effect suites 47 6,424,333 Tactile feedback man-machine interface device 48 6,411,276 Hybrid control of haptic feedback for host computer and interface device 49 6,400,352 Mechanical and force transmission for force feedback devices 50 6,380,925 Force feedback device with spring selection mechanism 51 6,374,255 Haptic authoring 52 6,366,273 Force feedback cursor control interface 53 6,366,272 Providing interactions between simulated objects using force feedback 54 6,353,850 Force feedback provided in web pages 55 6,353,427 Low cost force feedback device with actuator for non-primary axis 56 6,348,911 Force feedback device including safety switch and force magnitude ramping 57 6,343,349 Memory caching for force feedback effects 58 6,342,880 Force feedback system including multiple force processors 59 RE37,528 Direct-drive manipulator for pen-based force display 60 6,323,837 Method and apparatus for interfacing an elongated object with a computer system 61 6,317,116 Graphical click surfaces for force feedback applications to provide selection of functions using cursor interaction with a trigger position of a graphical object 62 6,310,605 Force feedback interface with selective disturbance filter 63 6,305,311 Kayak back-band installation assembly and method for installing a back-band in a kayak 64 6,304,091 Absolute position sensing by phase shift detection using a variable capacitor 65 6,300,938 Multiple-cylinder control device for computers and other electronic apparatus 66 6,300,937 Method and apparatus for controlling force feedback for a computer interface device 67 6,300,936 Force feedback system including multi-tasking graphical host environment and interface device 68 6,292,174 Enhanced cursor control using limited-workspace force feedback devices 69 6,292,170 Designing compound force sensations for computer applications 70 6,288,705 Interface device and method for providing indexed cursor control with force feedback 71 6,285,351 Designing force sensations for computer applications including sounds 72 6,281,651 Haptic pointing devices 73 6,278,439 Method and apparatus for shaping force signals for a force feedback device 74 6,271,833 Low cost force feedback peripheral with button activated feel sensations 75 6,271,828 Force feedback interface devices providing resistance forces using a fluid 76 6,259,382 Isotonic-isometric force feedback interface 77 6,256,011 Multi-function control device with force feedback 78 6,252,583 Memory and force output management for a force feedback system 79 6,252,579 Interface device and method for providing enhanced cursor control with force feedback 80 6,246,390 Multiple degree-of-freedom mechanical interface to a computer system 81 6,243,078 Pointing device with forced feedback button 82 6,232,891 Force feedback interface device having isometric functionality 83 6,219,033 Method and apparatus for controlling force feedback interface systems utilizing a host computer 84 6,219,032 Method for providing force feedback to a user of an interface device based on interactions of a controlled cursor with graphical elements in a graphical user interface 85 6,211,861 Tactile mouse device 86 6,201,533 Method and apparatus for applying force in force feedback devices using friction 87 6,195,592 Method and apparatus for providing tactile sensations using an interface device 88 6,191,774 Mouse interface for providing force feedback 89 6,184,868 Haptic feedback control devices 90 6,169,540 Method and apparatus for designing force sensations in force feedback applications 91 6,166,723 Mouse interface device providing force feedback 92 6,161,126 Implementing force feedback over the World Wide Web and other computer networks 93 6,154,201 Control knob with multiple degrees of freedom and force feedback 94 6,154,198 Force feedback interface apparatus including backlash and for generating feel sensations 95 6,147,674 Method and apparatus for designing force sensations in force feedback computer applications 96 6,131,097 Haptic authoring 97 6,128,006 Force feedback mouse wheel and other control wheels 98 6,125,385 Force feedback implementation in web pages 99 6,104,382 Force feedback transmission mechanisms 100 6,104,158 Force feedback system 101 6,101,530 Force feedback provided over a computer network 102 6,100,874 Force feedback mouse interface 103 6,088,019 Low cost force feedback device with actuator for non-primary axis 104 6,078,308 Graphical click surfaces for force feedback applications to provide user selection using cursor interaction with a trigger position within a boundary of a graphical object 105 6,067,077 Position sensing for force feedback devices 106 6,061,004 Providing force feedback using an interface device including an indexing function 107 6,057,828 Method and apparatus for providing force sensations in virtual environments in accordance with host software 108 6,050,718 Method and apparatus for providing high bandwidth force feedback with improved actuator feel 109 6,046,727 Three dimensional position sensing interface with force output 110 6,037,927 Method and apparatus for providing force feedback to the user of an interactive computer simulation 111 6,028,593 Method and apparatus for providing simulated physical interactions within computer generated environments 112 6,024,576 Hemispherical, high bandwidth mechanical interface for computer systems 113 6,020,876 Force feedback interface with selective disturbance filter 114 6,020,875 High fidelity mechanical transmission system and interface device 115 6,015,473 Method for producing a precision 3-D measuring apparatus 116 5,999,168 Haptic accelerator for force feedback computer peripherals 117 RE36,387 Percussion input device for personal computer systems 118 5,959,613 Method and apparatus for shaping force signals for a force feedback device 119 5,956,484 Method and apparatus for providing force feedback over a computer network 120 5,929,846 Force feedback interface device including grounded sensor system 121 5,929,607 Low cost force feedback interface with efficient power sourcing 122 5,907,487 Force feedback device with safety feature 123 5,903,456 Withdrawn 124 5,889,672 Tactiley responsive user interface device and method therefor 125 5,889,670 Method and apparatus for tactilely responsive user interface 126 5,880,714 Three-dimensional cursor control interface with force feedback 127 5,828,197 Mechanical interface having multiple grounded actuators 128 5,825,308 Force feedback interface having isotonic and isometric functionality 129 5,821,920 Control input device for interfacing an elongated flexible object with a computer system 130 5,805,140 High bandwidth force feedback interface using voice coils and flexures 131 5,767,839 Method and apparatus for providing passive force feedback to human-computer interface systems 132 5,739,811 Method and apparatus for controlling human-computer interface systems providing force feedback 133 5,734,373 Method and apparatus for controlling force feedback interface systems utilizing a host computer 134 5,731,804 Method and apparatus for providing high bandwidth, low noise mechanical I/O for computer systems 135 5,724,264 Method and apparatus for tracking the position and orientation of a stylus and for digitizing a 3-D object 136 5,721,566 Method and apparatus for providing damping force feedback 137 5,701,140 Method and apparatus for providing a cursor control interface with force feedback 138 5,691,898 Safe and low cost computer peripherals with force feedback for consumer applications 139 5,623,582 Computer interface or control input device for laparoscopic surgical instrument and other elongated mechanical objects 140 D377,932 Mechanical digitizing arm used to input three dimensional data into a computer 141 5,576,727 Electromechanical human-computer interface with force feedback 142 5,438,529 Percussion input device for personal computer systems |