In a sense, the votes had more to do with politics than policy. Mr. Frist knew going into the debate that the measures were likely to be blocked but wanted to put Democrats on record before the midterm elections in November. After the votes, he issued a news release headlined "Frist Denounces Democrat Obstruction of Medical Liability Reform."

Bad law is still bad law and screwing people over to protect the bank accounts of insurance companies is always going to be bad law.

Senate Rejects Award Limits in Malpractice - New York Times