Create an Account
username: password:
 
  MemeStreams Logo

Iraqing Their Brains - How can the Democratic candidates escape the trap they set for themselves? By Michael Kinsley

search

ryan is the supernicety
My Blog
My Profile
My Audience
My Sources
Send Me a Message

sponsored links

ryan is the supernicety's topics
Arts
Business
Games
Health and Wellness
Home and Garden
Miscellaneous
Current Events
Recreation
Local Information
Science
Society
Sports
Technology

support us

Get MemeStreams Stuff!


 
Iraqing Their Brains - How can the Democratic candidates escape the trap they set for themselves? By Michael Kinsley
Topic: Society 11:50 am EST, Dec 12, 2003

] If they say yes, supporting the war was a mistake, they
] are declaring that in a test case of the most important
] decision a president must make—when to go to war—they
] got it wrong. And if they try to explain their way out of
] this by talking about how the Bush administration
] "deceived the American people," they sound like George
] Romney, who was laughed out of the 1968 presidential race
] for saying he had been "brainwashed" into supporting the
] war in Vietnam.
]
]
] On the other hand, if they say no, I don't regret my
] support for this war, the question naturally arises:
] Well, if everything you're complaining about doesn't
] change your mind about the war itself, why are you making
] such an unholy fuss? Apparently, if you had been
] president, we'd be in the same mess.
]
]
] Like mice frustrated in a maze, the candidates seek
] escape routes out of this logical trap. Sometimes they
] say that the current mess is not the result of the
] decision to go to war. It is the result of Bush's inept
] leadership during the war and/or the postwar occupation.
] He should have waited longer for diplomacy to work. He
] should have insisted on the participation of other big
] countries instead of going it virtually alone. He should
] have been better-prepared for the challenges of
] rebuilding. He should not have been blindsided by
] continued opposition after the official fighting stopped.
]
]
] But the resolution these gentlemen supported gave
] war-making authority to George W. Bush, not to some
] idealized, all-knowing president such as themselves. The
] resolution did not say, "This authorization to start a
] war is valid only when used in conjunction with at least
] two other countries large enough to spot on a
] medium-sized world map." Nor did it tell Bush to wait
] until … until … until when? The resolution gave
] George W. Bush the authority to decide when the waiting
] for friends to join in or the foe to back down had gone
] on long enough. If Bush bungled this authority,
] entrusting him with it was a big mistake.

Good breakdown of the logical fallicies of the Democratic candidates positions on Iraq. a quick read worth reading.

Iraqing Their Brains - How can the Democratic candidates escape the trap they set for themselves? By Michael Kinsley



 
 
Powered By Industrial Memetics
RSS2.0