|
Unused Audio Commentary By Howard Zinn & Noam Chomsky, Recorded Summer, 2002, for The Fellowship of the Ring (Platinum Series Extended Edition) DVD, Part Two by BridgetAG at 11:43 pm EDT, May 22, 2003 |
This is absolutely the driest humor I have ever come across. Two parts, slightly dated to winter of last year but spot on humor. Don't miss the analysis of the instabilities inherent in The Shire's pipe-weed based economy in Part 1. ] Chomsky: Is there any kind of idea that men should live ] in peace with the Orcs? ] ] ] Zinn: Think of the scenes in the prologue with all the ] arrows hitting these thousands of Orcs. We're supposed to ] think that this is a good thing. ] ] ] Chomsky: I think this is a tragedy, this story. Because ] it's about two cultures. And poor leadership. It's a ] human tragedy, and an Orcish tragedy. |
'Unused' Commentary on The Fellowship of the Ring - Is peace with the orcs possible? by Elonka at 1:35 pm EDT, May 23, 2003 |
Satirical "commentary" about the Fellowship of the Ring, from a different perspective on Good and Evil. In this commentary, Frodo is a Mohammed Atta character being sent on a suicide mission, the elves are militaristic genocide-mongers who are promoting an orc apartheid, the Black Riders are "misunderstood", the orcs are fighting a war of self-defense against the invading Fellowship, and Gandalf is a dictator attempting to control the media . . . ] This takes me back to the media's involvement in all ] this, and the way the media is being controlled by ] Gandalf, such as when he covers Saruman's palantir in ] Orthanc. This is the stone that allows one to see, and ] thus communicate with, different cultures. Question everything. ;) |
'Unused' Commentary on The Fellowship of the Ring - Is peace with the orcs possible? by Lost at 8:30 pm EDT, May 23, 2003 |
] Chomsky: Naturally, it's in Rohan/Gondor's interest to ] keep the Orcs obscured, to make everything as restricted ] and dehumanizing as possible. It's always the first step ] toward genocide. And is this %u2014 is there anything ] less than genocide being advocated in this film? ] ] Zinn: I don't think so. ] ] Chomsky: Is there any kind of idea that men should live ] in peace with the Orcs? |
There are redundant posts not displayed in this view from the following users: Andy, agarhti.
|
|