How about a significance rating system. One set of radio buttons for significance (Impending, Impotant, Neutral, Trivial, and Personal). Jeremy wrote: ] There are memes, and then there are Memes. Said another way: ] All memes are created equal, but some memes are more equal ] than others. ] ] I am quite dismayed and disappointed that MemeStreams allowed ] an entire week to pass without forcing me to read and ] recommend the essay by Philip Kennicott that appeared in the ] May 5 edition of the Washington Post. This should not have ] been allowed to happen. ] ] Between the time of publication and the time of this writing, ] I received several messages in my MemeBox, but none pointed to ] this essay. One of them was about a story in the Weekly World ] News. Another, which I ignored, appeared to be some kind of ] conspiracy theory involving the Mossad. A third item directed ] my attention to academically interesting but ultimately ] insignificant research results in the field of cryptanalysis. ] ] An analogous situation is known in computer science as a ] priority inversion. It is an undesirable condition, but steps ] can be taken to design it out of the system. At this point I ] am forced to consider whether MemeStreams has taken sufficient ] measures to minimize the occurrence of priority inversion. ] ] In part, the reputation agent is designed to solve this ] problem. By selecting and sorting available memes based on ] weighted adjacencies in the social network, the cream is ] supposed to rise to the top. ] ] For many users, memes pass through the reputation agent in ] particular much as ideas flow through the news media in ] general: here today, gone tomorrow. While this approach ] generally suffices for the run of the mill meme, it is ] woefully inadequate for that most rare, truly exemplary meme. ] A remedy must be devised. ] ] I have a proposal. It consists of one idea in two parts: gold ] stars and sticky bits. Allow me to explain. ] ] Each year, on the anniversary of your blog, you are issued a ] one year supply of gold stars to use as you see fit. A year's ] supply is on the order of eight to ten gold stars. Use them ] with care, because they must last you through the entire year. ] When you see a truly outstanding must-read-NOW meme that is ] simply not to be missed under any circumstances, even if it ] means running around a one-stoplight town at 2 a.m. with a ] PowerBook and a WiFinder, attach one of your gold stars to ] this article. Don't jump the gun, because once you attach the ] star, it cannot be revoked, it cannot be reused, and it will ] be present for all to see, for all time. ] ] The reputation agent knows about gold stars and takes notice ] when they appear. This is where the sticky bits come in. ] Starred memes are moved to the top of the stack, are ] unmistakably highlighted, with the normal white text on a blue ] background replaced by larger, bold white text on a red ] background. Regardless of the "TimeFrame" setting, these ] memes stay at the top of the stack until one of two actions is ] taken by the user. a) The user posts the meme to his/her ] weblog. b) The user explicitly dismisses the meme by clicking ] on a special purpose link at the bottom of the entry, next to ] the links for Thread, Recommend, and Reply. Like the Delete ] function, the Dismiss function prompts the user for ] confirmation, again presenting the description(s) provided by ] the user(s) who have attached (a) gold star(s) to the meme. ] ] At the expense of a slight increase in complexity, this ] mechanism could be protected against abuse by new users. For ] example, gold stars could be held in escrow and rationed out ] to new users, at a maximum of one per month. ] ] It is hoped that with gold stars and sticky bits, we can ] dramatically reduce the occurrence of missed excellence within ] the MemeStreams community. RE: On The Relative Importance and Urgency of Memes, and a Modest Proposal |