Create an Account
username: password:
 
  MemeStreams Logo

MemeStreams Discussion

search


This page contains all of the posts and discussion on MemeStreams referencing the following web page: Daily Kos || Weblogs are the liberal answer to talk shows. . You can find discussions on MemeStreams as you surf the web, even if you aren't a MemeStreams member, using the Threads Bookmarklet.

Daily Kos || Weblogs are the liberal answer to talk shows.
by Decius at 11:56 am EST, Mar 14, 2004

A CNN Political analyst has called weblogs the Liberal answer to Conservative talk shows.

] WATSON: Democrats have a new secret weapon.
]
] For a long time, you have heard Democrats complain that
] Republicans have conservative talk radio, that Rush
] Limbaugh, Sean Hannity and Bill O'Reilly and others have
] shaped the agenda and gotten people aroused and excited
] at the base. And finally, in 2004, Democrats have an
] answer. The answer is what? It's the blogs, the so-called
] Web logs, where people go online and write information,
] write commentary, post news stories.
]
] Very interesting study out of George Washington says
] about 15 to 20 million people are now actively using the
] Internet and these Web logs in particular, sites like
] Daily Kos and Talking Points Memo. And what's significant
] here is that Democrats are using this to shape the
] agenda, because, remember, lots of Washington reporters
] read these. They're using these to excite their own base,
] just like conservative talk show radio does.
]
] We've already seen that they use the Internet to raise
] money, but also they may turn out voters using this
] critical weapon.
]
] BLITZER: So you're thinking the these blogs on the
] Internet, these are sort of liberal-leaning, as talk
] radio is conservative- leaning?
]
] WATSON: Very much so. The blogs are the Democratic answer
] to conservative talk radio. The George Washington study
] says that of the people who they consider online
] political citizens, not 1 percent, not 2 percent, but 50
] percent are considered Democrat. Only 27 percent are
] considered Republicans.
]
] It doesn't mean that Republicans are not using the
] Internet. It doesn't mean they are not using blogs, just
] like there obviously are some liberal talk radio
] stations. But it means that right now liberals may have
] found their answer and the answer to conservative talk
] radio may be these blogs.

This is an interesting interpretation. The weblog community does seem to be heavily liberal.

The study, which you can grab from ipdi.org, is a discussion of whether online political citizens are what marketing people call "influentials." Basically, bell weathers who tell other people what to buy, who to vote for, etc... Apparently reading newspapers is still a better indicator that someone is an "influential" then using the internet, but for the most part "online political citizens" are people that campaigns need to be addressing.

The study draws a very different conclusion about the democratic bias then this commentator. They think its because the democrats have a primary this year. They seem to believe that if the U.S. had a democratic president the net would be swarming with republicans. I'm not sure I agree that its that simple.


 
RE: Daily Kos || Weblogs are the liberal answer to talk shows.
by Jeremy at 12:25 pm EST, Mar 14, 2004

Decius wrote:
]] BLITZER: So you're thinking the these blogs on the
]] Internet, these are sort of liberal-leaning, as talk
]] radio is conservative-leaning?
]]
]] WATSON: Very much so. The blogs are the Democratic answer
]] to conservative talk radio. The George Washington study
]] says that of the people who they consider online
]] political citizens, not 1 percent, not 2 percent, but
]] 50 percent are considered Democrat. Only 27 percent are
]] considered Republicans.

I don't know what it means to be "considered" Democrat or Republican. Last I knew, those labels are self-selected, not applied by some external arbiter.

Also, what about the other 23 percent? To me, the problem is as much with the study question as with the blogosphere. I'm inclined to interpret the results as saying that Democrats strongly identify to the party, whereas "Republican"-minded bloggers are more likely to present themselves as moderates. I'm not the least bit surprised by the present solidarity of the Democrats.

] [In] the study ... they think it's because
] the democrats have a primary this year. They seem to believe
] that if the US had a democratic president the net would be
] swarming with republicans. I'm not sure I agree that it's that
] simple.

I agree that the issue cannot be so neatly wrapped up, but I do think the blogosphere is event-driven to a much more significant degree than, say, the daily newspapers, or the monthly magazines, or the television newsmagazines, or the daily call-in shows. This is both a strength and a weakness.


  
RE: Daily Kos || Weblogs are the liberal answer to talk shows.
by Decius at 12:36 pm EST, Mar 14, 2004

Jeremy wrote:
] I don't know what it means to be "considered" Democrat or
] Republican. Last I knew, those labels are self-selected, not
] applied by some external arbiter.

The speaker is saying it wrong. The data comes from several surveys. You self select your label.

] Also, what about the other 23 percent?

Independent, or didn't specify.

] To me, the problem is
] as much with the study question as with the blogosphere.

Go read the paper. They asked a large number of people. Of the people who they ID as online political citizens, certain percentages were democrats... The overall dataset for one of the surveys was 36 d, 33r...


Daily Kos || Weblogs are the liberal answer to talk shows.
by k at 10:56 pm EST, Mar 14, 2004

A CNN Political analyst has called weblogs the Liberal answer to Conservative talk shows.
...
The study draws a very different conclusion about the democratic bias then this commentator. They think its because the democrats have a primary this year. They seem to believe that if the U.S. had a democratic president the net would be swarming with republicans. I'm not sure I agree that its that simple.

[ This is an interesting meme that's been floating around for a little while. It definitely seems to me like the majority of the organized blogging on the internet is left of center. I've spent some time trying to figure out why myself, and the first possible conclusion i came to is that my own bias is leading me to sites that trend my direction. That seems less and less likely anymore, now that other people and studies are showing the same kind of left orientaion. I thought it might be because the sort of people able to entertain a dialog online must be somewhat more open minded, which i think seems to be a hallmark of the left more than the right, in general.
Anyway, whatever reason, you can bet that the righties won't let it stay that way forever. Expect a sizable influx of conservative blogs to pop up and try to monopolize the mindshare. Unless they're somehow not wired to succeed in the diverse and chaotic sea that is the internet. -k]


 
 
Powered By Industrial Memetics